Eric Bruntlett and the Best Trade in Franchise History

In November 2007, the Phillies made the trade that, when all is said and done, will probably turn out to be the most significant in franchise history. Michael Bourn, Geoff Geary, and Michael Costanza were sent to the Houston Astros in return for Brad Lidge - and Eric Bruntlett. The value of Lidge needs no elaboration but it's easy to overlook Bruntlett even though his addition has already payed big dividends.

Bruntlett played five seasons with the Astros as a utility player averaging about .250 at the plate over that time. With the Phils, he was in effect replacing Michael Bourn who had served as Pat Burrell's legs in 2007. That is not to minimize the contribution of Bourn who provided excellent late-inning defense and in just over 100 at-bats, stole 18 bases and scored 29 runs. His speed - he probably could have anchored the Olympic 400m relay - was a huge factor in late game rallies. Losing Bourn was not trivial.

But Bruntlett, minus the explosive speed, is also an excellent athlete with the additional dimension of being able to play the infield. He filled in when Jimmy Rollins went down early last season and after a shaky start performed admirably. For the remainder of 2008, Eric reprised Bourn's role as Burrell's alter ego. Bruntlett hit only .217 for the season but came up with some key hits late in the campaign. He had a very strong spring and provided a pinch-hit double on opening night. With the Phillies' shortage of right-handed hitters on the bench, Eric Bruntlett has the opportunity to elevate his role on the club from pinch-runner and defensive replacement to offensive weapon.

You never know in baseball. Michael Bourn could win the Triple Crown. Geoff Geary might win the Cy Young Award. Michael Costanza might be named Rookie of the Year. But right now, Lidge and Bruntlett for Bourn, Geary and Costanza ranks right up there with the Louisiana Purchase.